Common Garden Pests in Canada: Slugs, Cutworms, Colorado Potato Beetle and Lily Leaf Beetle
Seedlings cut off overnight, potato leaves full of orange grubs, lilies chewed to skeletons and ragged holes in the lettuce: these four pests cause more frustration in Canadian vegetable and flower gardens than almost anything else. This guide explains how to identify slugs, cutworms, Colorado potato beetle and lily leaf beetle, when they strike, and how to control them with methods that Canadian provincial and university experts recommend, starting with the ones that don't need a spray at all.
The four pests at a glance
| Pest | What it attacks | Signs | Best first step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Slugs | Seedlings, leafy vegetables, most garden plants | Ragged holes in leaves, silvery slime trails | Remove hiding places, hand-pick at night |
| Cutworms | Young transplants and seedlings | Stems cut off at soil level overnight | Collars around transplants |
| Colorado potato beetle | Potatoes, eggplant, young tomatoes and peppers | Striped beetles, orange eggs, red-orange grubs | Hand-pick the first beetles in spring |
| Lily leaf beetle | True lilies and fritillaria | Bright red beetles, larvae covered in black frass | Hand-pick adults as lilies emerge |
Slugs
How to identify them
The BC Ministry of Agriculture's Home & Garden Pest Management Guide describes slugs as soft-bodied, shell-less relatives of snails, from 0.3 to 10 cm long, and orange, grey, brown or black in colour. They are most active at night or in damp weather, chewing large ragged holes in the leaves of most garden plants. Look for silvery, slimy trails on soil, grass and leaves.
Slugs aren't just a West Coast problem. The University of Saskatchewan notes that slugs are a relatively new pest for Saskatchewan gardeners. They arrived on greenhouse plants shipped from other provinces and states, and as the Prairie climate warms, conditions are becoming more favourable for them.
What works
Both the BC guide and the University of Saskatchewan recommend:
- Remove daytime hiding places. The BC guide lists boards, stones, weedy areas, low branches and dense ground covers as ideal shelters.
- Hand-pick at night. Go out with a flashlight in the evening, or on cloudy and rainy days, and drop slugs into soapy water.
- Trap them under boards or rinds. Place boards, grapefruit or melon rinds, or cabbage leaves on the ground overnight, then flip them and destroy the slugs hiding underneath.
- Use beer traps. Sink containers of beer or fermented yeast at ground level so slugs crawl in and drown.
- Water less. The University of Saskatchewan recommends low-water landscaping habits, since slugs like cool, moist places.
- Encourage predators. Mulching with shredded wood provides habitat for egg-eating predators, and birds eat slugs.
- Fit slug guards on raised beds. A thin plastic lip shaped like an upside-down L around the bed edges stops slugs climbing in, according to the University of Saskatchewan.
What the experts disagree on
The University of Saskatchewan says eggshells, copper, coffee grounds, grass mulch and compost are not effective barriers, because slugs' thick slime protects them, and that diatomaceous earth doesn't work as a barrier either. The BC guide, on the other hand, suggests zinc or copper strips around raised beds and diatomaceous earth around plants. If you try barriers, treat them as a supplement to hand-picking and habitat changes, not a replacement.
The University of Saskatchewan also warns against salt, which damages soil and compost.
Slug baits
Where slugs are a serious problem, the BC guide recommends baits containing ferric phosphate (iron phosphate). It says they can be used safely without the risk of poisoning pets and wildlife, and are as effective as metaldehyde baits but much safer. Ferric phosphate is on Ontario's Allowable List for cosmetic pesticide use. The BC guide warns that metaldehyde baits are a risk to dogs, cats, birds and wildlife and should only be used in bait stations, and never on plants after the edible parts have formed.
Cutworms
How to identify them
Cutworms are the caterpillars of several species of night-flying moths. The University of Saskatchewan describes them as up to 5 cm long when fully grown, brown, grey or green, and curling into a tight "C" when disturbed. The BC guide notes that most emerge from the soil at night to feed and return to the soil during the day, so you usually find the damage in the morning but not the culprit.
Typical damage: Young plants cut off near the soil surface. When the cut isn't complete, plants may simply wilt. The University of Saskatchewan notes that cutworms are common in new gardens dug out of former lawn or pasture, since some species prefer grasses. Strawberry cutworms also cut leaf and flower stems and bore into strawberry crowns.
How to control them
- Use collars. The University of Saskatchewan suggests collars made from cardboard tubes, milk cartons, tin cans or plastic containers with both ends removed, pushed 5 cm into the soil around each transplant. The BC guide recommends them for plants such as tomatoes and cabbage, but notes they don't suit closely seeded crops like peas and beans.
- Hunt at night. Check plants with a flashlight after dark and hand-pick cutworms. During the day, lightly rake the top few centimetres of soil around damaged plants to find them.
- Clean up. Remove plant debris after harvest, because moths lay eggs on plant litter in late summer, and keep the garden weed-free.
- Try beneficial nematodes. The BC guide suggests watering insect-parasitic nematodes into the soil about a week before setting out transplants, once the soil has warmed in late May.
- Protect natural enemies. The University of Saskatchewan lists birds, ground beetles, parasitic wasps and flies, ants and rove beetles as natural predators, and advises against using broad insecticides on cutworms because they kill these beneficial insects too.
- Use Btk for severe infestations. Both sources mention Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki (Btk), which kills caterpillars that eat treated leaves and stems. Btk is on Ontario's Allowable List.
Colorado potato beetle
How to identify it
Manitoba Agriculture describes the adult as about 10 mm long and 6.5 mm wide, with a rounded shell marked with 10 alternating black and yellow stripes and a tan-orange head with black markings. Its eggs are yellow-orange and laid in clusters of 20 to 40 on the underside of leaves. The larvae are soft, humpbacked and reddish-tan with two rows of black spots along each side.
It's mainly a pest of potatoes, and to a lesser extent eggplant, tomato and pepper, according to the University of Saskatchewan. The BC guide notes that it isn't a problem in coastal BC but is becoming more common in the Interior.
Life cycle
The University of Saskatchewan and Manitoba describe it this way:
- Adults overwinter in the soil, as deep as 20 to 25 cm, in or near last year's potato patch.
- They emerge in late May or early June, feed on the first potato shoots, and mate.
- Each female lays 300 to 500 eggs between June and late July.
- Larvae feed for 2 to 5 weeks, then burrow into the soil to pupate.
- New adults emerge 1 to 3 weeks later, feed, then look for a place to overwinter.
On the Prairies there is usually one generation per year. The BC guide says there may be two in BC.
Manitoba notes that uncontrolled populations can completely strip potato plants and wipe out the tuber crop, and that feeding hurts yields most within two weeks of peak flowering.
How to control it
- Rotate. Don't grow potatoes in or near the same spot for at least three years, the University of Saskatchewan advises.
- Hand-pick the first beetles. Removing the first flush of adults in spring reduces eggs, larvae and later beetles. Wear disposable gloves or wash your hands afterwards, since the University of Saskatchewan notes the beetles contain a chemical that can irritate sensitive skin.
- Squash egg clusters on the undersides of leaves, or drop infested leaves into soapy water.
- Plant a trap crop. The University of Saskatchewan suggests planting four or five early potato plants as soon as the soil thaws, picking beetles off them, and planting your main crop in mid-June. The BC guide suggests eggplant as a trap plant.
- Use floating row covers. Put them on before plants emerge and leave them in place until the end of June.
- Choose early varieties. The BC guide recommends early-maturing potatoes harvested promptly, to starve late-season beetles.
- Remove nightshade weeds, which the beetles also eat.
If you need a spray, the BC guide suggests pyrethrins for larger infestations or older larvae, following label instructions and days-to-harvest intervals. Manitoba warns that insecticide-resistant populations have been found on the Prairies, which is another reason to rely on hand-picking and rotation first.
Lily leaf beetle (red lily beetle)
How to identify it
The red or scarlet lily beetle (Lilioceris lilii) is the pest every Canadian lily grower dreads. The University of Saskatchewan describes adults as 0.5 to 1 cm long, with a bright red back and a black head, antennae, legs and underside. Olds College notes that its body is elongated with no spots, which separates it from ladybugs.
- They drop and hide. When disturbed, adults fall to the ground upside down, and their black underside makes them hard to see. They can also squeak when squeezed.
- Larvae are disguised. The plump, slug-like larvae are orange, yellow or brown, but cover themselves with their own black excrement. From a distance they look like bird droppings or clumps of dirt.
- Eggs are bright red-orange, laid in irregular lines of 2 to 16 on the undersides of leaves and on buds.
Where it's found and what it eats
The beetle was first found in North America in Montreal in 1943, according to the University of Saskatchewan, and has spread south and west. Olds College reports that it is now found in every province except British Columbia. It spreads by flying and by hitchhiking on nursery plants.
It feeds almost exclusively on true lilies (Lilium) and fritillaria, including Saskatchewan's provincial flower, the western red lily. It does not feed on daylilies. Adults sometimes nibble on hostas, Solomon's seal, lily of the valley and a few other plants, but only cause minor damage there and don't lay eggs on them.
Life cycle and damage
The University of Saskatchewan explains that adults emerge in spring as the first lily shoots appear, then mate and lay eggs. Females can lay 205 to 450 eggs, eggs hatch in 6 to 10 days, and larvae feed for 2 to 3 weeks before pupating in the soil. New adults emerge in mid-summer and feed until fall. There's one generation a year, but adults can live for several years. Both adults and larvae chew holes in leaves, stems and buds, and larvae do the most damage, sometimes stripping plants completely.
How to control it
- Hand-pick early and often. The University of Saskatchewan calls hand-picking the most common and often most effective control. Start as soon as lilies emerge, because removing adults before they mate and lay eggs cuts down larvae later.
- Check leaf undersides for eggs and larvae and squish them, wearing gloves.
- Try Oriental lilies. The University of Saskatchewan notes that most Asiatic lilies are highly susceptible, while some Oriental varieties such as 'Uchida' and 'Defender Pink' have shown resistance.
- Inspect new lilies before planting to avoid bringing beetles home.
- Use soaps or oils only as a last resort. The University of Saskatchewan says insecticidal soaps and some horticultural oils have shown some effect when applied every 5 to 7 days after eggs hatch, but they also harm beneficial insects and are often no more effective than hand-picking.
A Canadian biocontrol success
A tiny parasitic wasp, Tetrastichus setifer, attacks only lily beetle larvae and doesn't sting people. The University of Saskatchewan reports successful trials in Ottawa, Olds, Edmonton, Calgary and Winnipeg. Olds College reports that after releases from 2014 to 2016, the wasp is well established in Olds, Airdrie and most of Calgary, and asks gardeners not to use chemical controls where it has been released. The wasps are not available to buy.
Using pesticides legally in Canada
If cultural controls aren't enough, any product you use must be registered by Health Canada's Pest Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA). The BC guide explains that the registration number must appear on the label, home gardeners should use products marked "Domestic," and both the plant and the pest must be listed on the label. Ontario and several other provinces restrict cosmetic pesticide use on lawns and gardens, so check the rules where you live. Our guide to natural vs chemical pest control in Canada explains the provincial rules.
The BC guide also notes that homemade pest remedies are not recommended, because many aren't effective and some damage plants or are hazardous.
A season-long plan for Canadian vegetable and flower gardens
- Clean up in fall. Remove plant debris and weeds to reduce cutworm egg sites and slug hiding places.
- Plan your rotation. Don't plant potatoes where they grew in the last three years.
- Start scouting as soon as shoots appear. Check lilies daily for red beetles and potatoes for striped adults.
- Collar transplants. Put a collar around every tomato, cabbage and pepper transplant as you plant it.
- Cover potatoes. Install floating row covers before potatoes emerge and keep them on until the end of June.
- Hunt at night. Go out with a flashlight to hand-pick slugs and cutworms during damp spells.
- Check leaf undersides weekly. Squash Colorado potato beetle and lily beetle eggs and larvae.
- Use registered products only if needed. Choose ferric phosphate slug bait, Btk for cutworms or a registered spray for beetles, and follow the label exactly.
Frequently asked questions
Do beer traps really work for slugs?
They can help. Both the BC Ministry of Agriculture and the University of Saskatchewan list beer or fermented yeast traps as an option. Sink the container near ground level.
Is iron phosphate slug bait safe for pets?
The BC Home & Garden Pest Management Guide says ferric phosphate baits can be used without the risk of poisoning pets and wildlife, unlike metaldehyde. Always follow the label.
What's cutting my seedlings off at the soil line?
Most likely cutworms. Check the soil around damaged plants during the day, or look with a flashlight at night, for curled-up caterpillars.
How do I tell a lily beetle from a ladybug?
Lily beetles are bright red with no spots and have an elongated body with a black head and legs. Ladybugs are rounder and usually have black spots.
Does the lily beetle eat daylilies?
No. The University of Saskatchewan notes that it does not feed on daylilies (Hemerocallis), which are not true lilies.
Why do Colorado potato beetles keep coming back?
Adults overwinter in the soil in and around last year's potato patch. Rotating crops at least three years apart, removing nightshade weeds and hand-picking the first beetles in spring all reduce numbers over time.
Should I spray insecticide for cutworms?
The University of Saskatchewan advises against it, because insecticides also kill the ground beetles, parasitic wasps and other insects that eat cutworms. Use collars and hand-picking, and Btk only if the infestation is severe.
Related guides
- Natural vs chemical pest control in Canada: what's legal and what works
- Japanese beetle in Canada: identify, control and regulated areas
- Late blight on tomatoes and potatoes in Canada
- The 5 easiest vegetables for a short Canadian growing season
- Common indoor plant pests: identify and treat them
Sources
- British Columbia Ministry of Agriculture, Home & Garden Pest Management Guide for British Columbia (2019): Chapter 15, Pests of vegetables (PDF) and Chapter 8, Using pesticides to manage pests (PDF).
- University of Saskatchewan, Slugs, Cutworms, Colorado potato beetle and Red/scarlet lily beetle.
- Manitoba Agriculture, Colorado potato beetle.
- Olds College, The lily beetle.
- Government of Ontario, Guide to Pesticide Classes (Allowable List).
- Health Canada, Pesticide label search.
Image credits
- Featured image (Potato): Tavo Romann / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 4.0. Source.
- Potato: Adámozphoto / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0. Source.
- Lily: Dinkum / Wikimedia Commons / CC0. Source.
- Lily: 5snake5 / Wikimedia Commons / CC0. Source.
- Seedling: W.M. Hantsbarger, Bugwood.org / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 3.0 US. Source.
- Slug: Paul Harrison / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0. Source.