Black Spot on Roses in Canada: How to Identify, Prevent and Control It
If your roses are covered in black blotches by midsummer and dropping yellow leaves onto the mulch, you are probably looking at black spot. Iowa State University Extension calls it one of the most common and important rose diseases, found wherever roses are grown. In Canada it is a regular problem in wet summers from Vancouver Island to Nova Scotia, and it turns up on the Prairies too.
Black spot rarely kills a rose outright, but year after year of leaf loss weakens the plant. That matters a great deal in Canada, where a rose needs all its strength to survive the winter. This guide explains how to recognize black spot, why it flares up in Canadian summers, which hardy roses resist it best, and how to control it with as little spraying as possible.
What causes black spot?
Black spot is caused by the fungus Diplocarpon rosae. It infects only roses (Rosa species), so it will not spread to your perennials or vegetables.
The University of Maine Cooperative Extension explains how the fungus works:
- It survives the winter on fallen leaves and in lesions on the canes. The spores do not survive in the soil.
- In spring, rain and watering splash spores from old leaves and canes onto new growth.
- Leaves must stay wet for at least seven hours before the spores can germinate.
- Within about two weeks, the new spots produce fresh spores, which spread by wind, splashing water, insects, hands and tools. Each new round of infection makes the problem worse as summer goes on.
The University of Maryland Extension adds that young leaves are the most susceptible and that cane lesions are the most important source of spores the following season. That is why fall and spring clean-up make such a difference.
How to identify black spot
Black spot usually starts on lower leaves and works its way up the plant. Look for these signs:
- Black or dark purple spots on the upper leaf surface. The Nova Scotia Department of Agriculture describes them as nearly circular, 2 to 12 mm across, with fringed or feathery margins. This fringe is the best clue.
- Yellowing around the spots. As the infection gets worse, the yellow spreads until the whole leaflet turns yellow.
- Leaf drop. Yellow leaves fall early. In bad years a rose can lose most of its leaves by August.
- Purple to black blotches on young canes. Nova Scotia notes raised, reddish-purple to black blotches on first-year wood.
- Fewer flowers. Iowa State notes that if black spot is left unchecked, plants produce fewer blooms each year.
Several other problems can look similar. Rose rust produces orange pustules on the underside of leaves. Powdery mildew is a white, dusty coating; see our powdery mildew guide. Yellow leaves without dark spots can point to watering or nutrient problems instead. If in doubt, take photos of the leaves and canes to a local garden centre or Master Gardener group.
Why black spot is common in Canadian summers
Black spot loves warm, wet weather. The Nova Scotia fact sheet notes that the fungus is most able to infect leaves at 19 to 21 °C, and that symptoms appear within three to four days at 22 to 30 °C. Iowa State gives an ideal range of about 24 to 29 °C (75 to 85 °F) with high humidity. The University of Maine notes that temperatures of about 29 °C (85 °F) and higher slow the disease.
That makes much of the Canadian summer ideal, especially:
- Rainy stretches in coastal BC, Ontario, Quebec and Atlantic Canada.
- Gardens watered with sprinklers in the evening, when leaves stay wet all night.
- Shady, crowded beds where leaves dry slowly.
The Comox Valley Regional District in BC notes that black spot is most often a problem in summers with long rainy periods. The Nova Scotia fact sheet also warns that during extended cool, wet weather, any rose can be seriously infected, even one with good resistance.
Which roses resist black spot?
Choosing a resistant rose is the single most effective step. The University of Maryland notes that resistance can vary from region to region, so treat ratings as a guide rather than a promise.
Roses that tend to be more susceptible
- Hybrid teas. The Comox Valley Regional District and Iowa State both note that many hybrid teas are susceptible.
- Yellow and copper-coloured roses. Iowa State lists most yellow and copper-coloured roses among the highly susceptible types.
Hardy roses for Canada and black spot
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada (AAFC) bred the Explorer and Parkland roses for Canadian winters, and later the Canadian Artists series. These roses are hardier than hybrid teas, but they are not all equally resistant to black spot. An unsprayed six-year trial at the Chicago Botanic Garden in the 1990s found:
- The Rosa rugosa types, including 'Jens Munk', 'David Thompson', 'Henry Hudson' and 'Martin Frobisher', showed the best resistance. 'Jens Munk' was the only Explorer rose rated fully resistant.
- 'William Baffin', a climbing Explorer, showed only minor black spot damage.
- Several roses, including 'John Franklin' and some Parkland (Morden) roses, lost more than 75 per cent of their leaves to black spot.
Newer AAFC roses have their own records. CFIA's Plant Breeders' Rights description states that the climbing Canadian Artists rose 'Félix Leclerc' is resistant to mildew and black spot. AAFC's HortScience release of 'Emily Carr' reports that it is slightly susceptible to black spot, observed only on the Prairies.
The Comox Valley Regional District also notes that shrub roses and rugosa roses are generally more resistant than hybrid teas, and that black spot is not likely to cause long-term damage to resistant native rose species.
| Rose | Type | Black spot rating | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 'Jens Munk' | Explorer (rugosa hybrid) | Resistant | Chicago Botanic Garden trial |
| 'David Thompson', 'Henry Hudson', 'Martin Frobisher' | Explorer (rugosa hybrids) | Minor damage | Chicago Botanic Garden trial |
| 'William Baffin' | Explorer (climber) | Minor damage | Chicago Botanic Garden trial |
| 'John Franklin' | Explorer | Susceptible | Chicago Botanic Garden trial |
| 'Félix Leclerc' | Canadian Artists (climber) | Resistant | CFIA Plant Breeders' Rights |
| 'Emily Carr' | Canadian Artists | Slightly susceptible on the Prairies | AAFC, HortScience 2008 |
| Most hybrid teas | Hybrid tea | Often susceptible | Iowa State; Comox Valley RD |
Ratings from different trials and climates; resistance can vary in your garden.
For more on growing these roses, see our Explorer rose page and our list of hardy perennials for zones 3 and 4.
How to prevent black spot
- Choose resistant roses. Start with rugosa types, 'Jens Munk' or other roses with a good local track record. Ask your local garden centre which roses stay clean in your area.
- Plant in full sun with room for air. Iowa State and the University of Maine both recommend open, sunny sites with good spacing so leaves dry quickly. Avoid planting roses among dense shrubs or tight against fences.
- Water the soil, not the leaves. Use a soaker hose or water at the base. If you must water overhead, do it early in the morning so leaves dry before evening, as Iowa State advises. The University of Maine also suggests avoiding wetting the leaves on dark, cloudy days.
- Mulch in spring. The Comox Valley Regional District suggests mulching roses in spring to help prevent spores on the ground from splashing onto new leaves.
- Prune for air flow. Remove crowded, crossing or weak canes in spring, and cut out any canes with dark lesions. Keep plants from growing into each other.
- Clean up every fall. Rake up and discard all fallen rose leaves, as the University of Maine recommends. The Comox Valley Regional District also suggests removing any old leaf debris in spring before new growth starts.
- Keep roses healthy. The Comox Valley Regional District recommends healthy, well-drained soil with plenty of organic matter. Healthy roses recover more easily from leaf loss.
How to control black spot once it appears
Remove infected leaves
Pick off spotted leaves as soon as you see them, ideally in dry weather, as the University of Maine suggests. The Comox Valley Regional District recommends removing infected leaves and branches promptly, even if that means taking off a lot of foliage, and putting them in the household garbage. Do not leave them on the ground, and do not add them to a home compost pile.
Keep up the cultural steps
Stop overhead watering, open up the plant by pruning, and keep the ground clean under your roses. These steps will not cure leaves that are already spotted, but they slow the spread to new growth.
Fungicides: prevention, not a cure
Fungicides protect healthy leaves; they do not repair spotted ones. The University of Maryland notes that on susceptible roses, most people need to spray every 7 to 14 days from when the first leaves appear in spring until fall, ideally before rain, alternating types of fungicide. The Nova Scotia fact sheet similarly recommends starting as leaves expand in spring and repeating every 10 to 14 days on susceptible cultivars.
Before you buy anything, keep these Canadian rules in mind:
- Use only registered products. In Canada, pesticides must be registered by Health Canada's Pest Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA). Check that the label has a PCP number and lists black spot on roses, and follow the directions exactly. You can search current products on the PMRA label search site. Older guides list fungicides that are no longer sold for home use, so always check the current label.
- Check provincial and municipal rules. Ontario allows cosmetic use on gardens only of products whose active ingredients are all on its Allowable List. Ontario's Guide to Pesticide Classes includes sulphur, lime sulphur, Bacillus subtilis, hydrogen peroxide and several copper compounds on that list. Other provinces and many municipalities have their own restrictions.
- Dormant sprays. The Comox Valley Regional District suggests a lime sulphur spray in spring before buds break to reduce overwintering spores. Use only a product registered for this purpose and follow the label carefully.
- Skip the homemade sprays. Baking soda and milk recipes are widely shared, but Health Canada advises against homemade pesticides, because they are not tested for safety or effectiveness.
If a rose gets black spot badly every year despite good care, consider replacing it with a more resistant variety rather than committing to spraying every summer.
Frequently asked questions
Will black spot kill my roses?
Rarely on its own. Iowa State notes that it reduces vigour and makes roses more susceptible to winter damage and other stresses. In Canada, that winter weakness is the real risk: a rose that loses its leaves every August goes into winter with fewer reserves.
Can I compost leaves with black spot?
It is best not to use a home compost pile. The Comox Valley Regional District recommends putting infected leaves and prunings in the household garbage. Fallen leaves are where the fungus spends the winter.
Should I remove all the leaves from an infected rose?
Remove leaves with spots and any that have fallen. The Comox Valley Regional District says to remove infected leaves and branches even if it means removing a lot of foliage. Leave healthy leaves on the plant so it can keep feeding itself.
Are Explorer roses resistant to black spot?
Some are, some are not. In the Chicago Botanic Garden trial, the rugosa-type Explorer roses, especially 'Jens Munk', resisted black spot best, while others, such as 'John Franklin', lost most of their leaves. Check ratings for the specific cultivar.
Does baking soda cure black spot?
No home remedy will cure leaves that are already spotted. Health Canada advises against homemade pesticides because they are untested and have no label directions. If you want a spray, choose a product registered by the PMRA for black spot on roses.
When does black spot appear in Canada?
Spots can show up in late spring, but the disease usually gets worse through mid and late summer after rainy spells. In the Chicago Botanic Garden trial, black spot sometimes appeared in mid-June but more often in late July and early August.
Can black spot spread to other plants?
No. Diplocarpon rosae infects only roses. It can spread from one rose to another by splashing water, wind, insects, hands and tools.
Related guides
- Powdery mildew: identify, prevent and treat it in Canada
- Top 10 hardy perennials for zones 3 and 4 on the Prairies
- Root rot in houseplants and garden plants
Sources
- Nova Scotia Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, Common Diseases of Roses (PDF).
- Comox Valley Regional District, Healthy Choices to Control Lawn and Garden Pests: Black Spot (PDF).
- Canadian Food Inspection Agency, Plant Breeders' Rights: 'Félix Leclerc' rose.
- Richer, C., Collicutt, L.M., Davidson, C.G., Dyck, L. and Lafond, C. (2008). 'Emily Carr' Canadian Artists Rose. HortScience 43(6). Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada.
- Chicago Botanic Garden, Plant Evaluation Notes: An Evaluation Report of Shrub Roses (PDF).
- Iowa State University Extension, Rose Black Spot.
- University of Maine Cooperative Extension, Black Spot of Rose.
- University of Maryland Extension, Black Spot Disease of Roses.
- Health Canada, The risks of homemade pesticides and Pesticide label search.
- Government of Ontario, Guide to Pesticide Classes (PDF).
Image credits
- Featured image (Rose): giantcicada / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 4.0. Source.
- Rose: giantcicada / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 4.0. Source.
- Rose: Stephen James McWilliam / Wikimedia Commons / CC0. Source.
- Rose: Therese Phillips / Wikimedia Commons / CC0. Source.
- Rose: Stephen James McWilliam / Wikimedia Commons / CC0. Source.
- Rugosa rose: AnRo0002 / Wikimedia Commons / CC0. Source.